Mentoring

Introduction

The University of Denver offers comprehensive Faculty Mentoring Programs aimed at supporting the professional development of faculty across ranks and series. These mentoring programs are designed to enhance faculty success and foster a supportive academic environment. By participating, faculty members can gain valuable insights, develop new skills, and contribute to a culture of continuous learning and mutual support.

Explore the programs to see how you can benefit from the resources and opportunities available through the Mentoring Programs at the University of Denver.

Mentoring Models

This section provides specific examples of mentoring activities that already take place at DU. It also includes ideas cultivated from the literature and other institutions that could provide platforms for developing mentoring activities that fit current faculty needs.

A variety of mentoring models exist (Figure 1) and they range in both structure and duration. For example, “Micro-mentoring” activities could include single, topical meetings or an “On call” model (Slack or Teams). This approach is highly useful for connecting new faculty to resources. Peer on Peer Circles – POP circles – are often longer in duration but contain less structure so they can evolve with faculty needs. Cross-identity mentoring might take place in any of these mentorship models; it is particularly important to consider mentor training for mentors in this context.

Types of mentoring and the time and structure involved.  Mentoring networks often encompass multiple modes of mentoring and multiple models for mentees to achieve their career goals. Affinity groups and cross-identity support is often incorporated into all models of mentoring.  Highlighting indicates the type of initiative; Yellow initiatives are for new faculty and blue initiatives are topical (i.e. chair support, teaching) or built around affinity groups. Figure adapted from The University of Washington’s Mentoring Toolkit

Figure 1: Types of mentoring and the time and structure involved.  Mentoring networks often encompass multiple modes of mentoring and multiple models for mentees to achieve their career goals. Affinity groups and cross-identity support is often incorporated into all models of mentoring.  Highlighting indicates the type of initiative; Yellow initiatives are for new faculty and blue initiatives are topical (i.e. chair support, teaching) or built around affinity groups. Figure adapted from The University of Washington’s Mentoring Toolkit

Existing Faculty Mentoring Programs/Initiatives at DU

Mentoring programs and models vary across the University of Denver to support the diversity in faculty lines and needs. For new faculty, the most common models include a traditional dyad (mentor/mentee pairing) and/or a small group cohort.   Below you will find lists of current DU mentoring programs. While DU has a variety of different mentoring programs, they are not currently actively administered or aligned across units.  It is important to remember that while mentoring programs are helpful and essential to faculty well-being, they are also not an answer to all university issues.

University Wide Mentoring Programs

Human Resources

Faculty Served: Faculty & Staff 
Approach: Mentor volunteers are listed so that mentees can contact them for support with personal, professional, and career-relaed development.

View the HRIC Mentor Program website for more information.

Faculty Affairs New Faculty Onboarding

Faculty Served: New appointed faculty 
Approach: Scaffolded experiences: welcomes, stand alone workshops, links to existing resources; Canvas course; 3 years of programming.

View our New Faculty web page for more information.

Adjunct Teaching Excellence Certificate (ATEP)

Faculty Served: Adjunct/Part-time Faculty
Approach: Celebration of professional development for part-time faculty, including orientation, OTL programs, etc.

View the ATEP program website for more information.

Faculty Writing Support

Faculty Served: All faculty 
Appraoch: Faculty writing support groups, including Writing Accountability Groups and Writing in Place drop-in sessions.

View our Faculty Writing Support web page for more information. 

Chairs Advisory Board (CAB)

Faculty Served: Chairs and Directors 
Approach: Peer-to-peer mentoring and training for department chairs and program directors.

View the Chairs and Directors Handbook for more information. 

4D Mentoring Collaborative

Faculty Served: Faculty & Staff 
Approach: The newly established 4D Mentorship Collaborative is a community of university faculty and staff dedicated to fostering and advancing a rich and inclusive culture of mentorship at DU.

Fill out this 4D registration form to get connected or reach out to 4D Associate Director of Mentoring, Sam Anderson-Lehman

Department/Unit Led Mentoring Programs

College of Arts, Humanities, and Social Sciences

Faculty Served: New Appointed Faculty
Approach: New faculty mentoring program with two levels: a dyad pairing with a mentor from a different department, and the larger cohort with the new faculty and their mentors. The dyads and the cohort meet once per quarter, for a combined total of six meetings.  CAHSS mentors receive a stipend.

For more information, contact Andrea Stanton, Senior Associate Dean of CAHSS.

Daniels College of Business

Faculty Served: Two programs: 1) New Appointed Faculty, 2) All Appointed Faculty
Approach: 1) New Faculty Orientation: University resources, Promotion Review Process, Policies and Processes (e.g., IT, Annual Merit Review) and introduction to Daniels graduate and undergraduate programs.  

2) Yearly separate Zoom sessions with Associate Dean and representatives from Daniels Tenure Track and Teaching and Professional Promotion/Review Committees to discuss the review process

For more information, contact Kellie Keeling, Chair and Associate Professor for the Daniels College of Business Department of Business Information and Analytics

Graduate School of Social Work

Faculty Served: All appointed faculty
Approach: Utilizes a mentoring map to build a network of mentors that can help with specific topics. Pilot began with pre-tenure track faculty and will expand.

For more information, contact Michael Talamantes, Clinical Professor of Social Work. 

Morgridge College of Education

Faculty Served: New faculty (TT/TPF lines)
Approach: Mentoring program for new MCE faculty. Dyad model with a senior faculty and new faculty, built around mentee’s mentoring plan. Two meetings per quarter. In addition to dyads, for new faculty cohorts in their first year, there are monthly onboarding meetings covering many topics (e.g. instructional design, grants, promotion/tenure, wellness).

For more information, contact the Morgridge College of Education

NSM Teaching Group

Faculty Served: All faculty
Approach: Not mentoring, per se, but a group that collaborates on teaching practices.

For more information, contact Nic Ormes, NSM Associate Dean. 

University Libraries

Faculty Served: Assistant Professors
Approach: 1) New assistant/visiting assistant professors are formally paired with a professor that has attained promotion. 2) Monthly group mentoring meetings.  3) Onboarding committee for new assistant professors.

For more information, contact Bridget Farrell, Associate Professor and Coordinator of Library Instruction and Reference Services University Libraries. 

Women Organizing in Molecular Biosciences group (WOMBAT)

Faculty Served: Tenure line/tenured women with biomolecular focus in research. All levels.
Approach: A peer mentoring group focused on research. Collaborative with CU Anschutz. Meets monthly and includes 7-9 faculty.

For more information, contact Michelle Knowles, Professor of Natural Sciences and Mathematics. 

Biology Women’s Group

Faculty Served: Women faculty in biology, all levels, tenure and teaching lines
Approach: A peer group focused on mentoring women in Biology. Meets ~quarterly.

For more information, contact Anna Sher, Professor in the Department of Biological Sciences

STEM Women’s Faculty Association

Faculty Served: All Faculty
Approach: Monthly meetings in person/on zoom. Topics addressed are quite organic – usually center on university/college level issues.

For more information, view DU’s Women’s Coalition website

Frequently Asked Questions

What kind of mentor do I need?

This resource from Duke University’s graduate school describes the many roles a mentor may play (advisers, tutors, sponsors, supporters, experts, role models) and provides examples of what each of those roles might “look like” when applied. For example, a faculty member may want to: 1) connect with a mentor within their department to understand promotion expectations and procedures, 2) seek mentorship on teaching or research from those that may or may not reside in the same department (or institution), 3) seek a mentor that can help navigate cross-identities and challenges, 4) identify a mentor that is a colleague experiencing the same situation (peer-mentor).

What is a departmental mentoring plan?

Mentoring plans help departments or units to articulate how faculty will receive the mentoring and support they will need to be successful in their new or continuing roles. This mentoring plan from the University of Massachusetts Amherst helps mentoring teams to tailor plans to each new hire.

Are there practical solutions for match-making mentor-mentee pairings?

It helps if the mentee has clear goals for what they want or need in a mentor. Check out The University of Washington’s Mentoring Toolkit  if you are a mentee and need to identify goals for a mentoring relationship. Afterwards, a conversation with a chair, dean, or colleague could help identify new mentors that would fit at the university. For example, this could include identifying a mentor in the same line (e.g. teaching, tenure, etc) or with a certain skill (e.g. successful at receiving funding from the NSF) or an affinity group.

I don’t have time to do this in person. Are there virtual options?

Virtual mentoring or E-Mentoring build relationships through online media. The mentoring may take place entirely through electronic communication or could be developed in person and then move to an online format. Some online services in this area exist already, like MentorNet (http://mentornet.net), which is a free resource for women in Engineering and Science that matches students, post-docs, and early-career researchers across universities and within industry. The National Research Mentoring Network (NRMN; https://nrmnet.net/) provides similar opportunities to make connections with a mentor based on your desired search criteria and to explore long-term mentoring connections with guided prompts that help facilitate mentorship relationships. NRMN specifically serves the biomedical, behavioral, clinical, and social sciences. 

How do I motivate faculty to participate as mentors?
  1.  Acknowledge and reward mentorship within the typical research, service, teaching review categories during merit reviews.
  2. Provide funding to support mentoring (e.g. for mentor/mentee to have lunch/coffee).
  3. Recognize mentors in promotion/reappointment to show that mentorship is valued. For example, other universities offer mentoring awards.
  4. At DU, CAHSS provides faculty mentors with a stipend.
  5. Remember to not  over-burden certain identity groups as mentors.
How do I identify and communicate what I want out of a mentoring relationship?
  1. The National Center for Faculty Development and Diversity’s mentoring map can help faculty identify mentorship needs. 
  2. The GSSW mentoring map for mentees also highlights different areas where mentors may be needed.
  3. The Teaching and Professional Faculty Lifecycle identifies mentoring focal points across a faculty’s career from onboarding through promotion and retirement.
  4. Mentoring agreements/plans are common in traditional mentor-mentee relationships. They define meeting frequency, goal-setting, and the expectations of each person. Links to several examples are available in the Selected Programs at Other Institutions section above.
I’ve noticed that faculty in my unit need advice on certain, sometimes detailed, topics. How can I handle that?

Psychology has a skill matching program for graduate students that might be a good model for faculty as well. Graduate students volunteer their expertise and all new students receive a list of topics they might need mentorship or other help around with contact information for potential topical mentors. Here’s a table from the University of Iowa where expertise/needs can be identified for some common faculty topics.

Why should I be a mentor? What’s in it for me?

Mentoring improves job satisfaction and can build valued relationships. It can help you understand what your colleagues need and help them be successful and stay at DU. This could mean that you have one less search committee in the future. It also is a service activity that can be added to Workload Equity dashboards, if they exist in your unit, and in annual evaluations.

How do I know if I need a mentor? What kind of mentoring do I need?

 Evidence shows that most people benefit from having mentors, from students to early career faculty to mid-career and beyond. For example, a mentor could be useful when transitioning research, teaching a new course, earning promotion, or taking on leadership roles at DU. The National Center for Faculty Development and Diversity’s mentoring map can help faculty identify mentorship needs. 

How do I find the right mentor?

Pairing can happen by identifying what you are specifically in need of. See the GSSW program for useful structures. After identifying needs, a chair, director or colleague could help identify good mentors. The Writing Program uses small group mentor cohorts, which takes some pressure off dyad pairings and adds more voices to the mix.

What training do I need to be a mentor?

There are numerous resources available to help train mentors in core mentoring skills. This document from North Carolina State University provides some fantastic resources to start mentor training in your unit. There is also training available online, for instance, through NCFDD and CIMER, and mentoring training is being developed in various units at DU (for instance, through the MERISTEM ADVANCE grant programming, through the VPFA’s Mentoring community of practice, and in the Writing Program). 

 

I don’t have much time, but I want to help. What should I do?

Consider getting coffee with a new colleague to check-in or participating in any micro-mentoring or online mentoring opportunities in your college or unit.

Helpful References

National Center for Faculty Development and Diversity:

DU faculty can access an individual membership at the National Center for Faculty Development & Diversity (NCFDD) by registering for an account using their DU email address. DU has an institutional membership that makes this possible. The NCFDD offers resources, events, and webinars that foster faculty development and success in areas like research, teaching, and time management (https://www.facultydiversity.org/).

Peer Coaching: 

Shelton, D. S., Delgado, M. M., Greenway, E. V. G., Hobson, E. A., Lackey, A. C. R., Medina-García, A., Reinke, B. A., Trillo, P. A., Wells, C. P., & Horner-Devine, M. C. (2021). Expanding the landscape of opportunity: Professional societies support early-career researchers through community programming and peer coaching. Journal of Comparative Psychology, 135(4), 439–449. https://doi.org/10.1037/com0000300

Mentoring Networks:

Termini CM, Hinton AO Jr, Garza-López E, Koomoa DL, Davis JS, Martínez-Montemayor MM. Building Diverse Mentoring Networks that Transcend Boundaries in Cancer Research. Trends Cancer. 2021 May;7(5):385-388. doi: 10.1016/j.trecan.2021.01.001. 

Mentoring Across Difference:

Crawford, K. and Smith, D. (2005). The we and the us: Mentoring African American women. Journal of black studies, vol 36.1, Sept. 2005, pp. 52-67.

Kanuka, H. and Marini, A. (2004). Empowering untenured faculty through mosaic mentoring. Canadian Journal of University Continuing Education 30.2, Fall 2004. Pp 11-38.

Reddick, R. J. and Saenz, V. B. (2012). Coming home: Hermanos academicos reflect on past and present realities as professors at their alma mater. Harvard educational review. 82.3, Fall 2012.

Stanley, C. A., and Lincoln, Y. S. (2005). Cross-race faculty mentoring. Change, vol 37.2. pp. 44-50.